The importance of civility in the practice of law

2023 July

Last month, CAALA inducted into its Hall of Fame four fine lawyers: Gary Dordick, Carl Douglas, Gretchen Nelson, and Brian Panish. Each of these represents the highest ideals of civility in our profession.

The legal profession is built on principles that strive for justice, fairness, and respect for the rule of law. At the core of this noble pursuit lies the concept of legal civility, which refers to the courteous and respectful behavior exhibited by legal professionals throughout their practice. Legal civility fosters an environment of professionalism, cooperation, and effective dispute resolution. I’d like to explore the significance of legal civility in the practice of law and how it contributes to a fair and efficient judicial system.

Promoting professionalism

Legal civility plays a vital role in promoting professionalism within the legal community. Lawyers are not only representatives of their clients but also officers of the court. By maintaining civility, legal practitioners uphold the integrity and reputation of the profession. When lawyers treat each other with respect, it strengthens the public’s trust in the legal system. Professionalism also ensures that lawyers can collaborate effectively, fostering a cooperative atmosphere where legal issues are addressed efficiently.

Preserving the adversarial process

The adversarial nature of the legal system relies on opposing parties presenting their arguments and evidence before an impartial judge or jury. While vigorous advocacy is a cornerstone of this process, legal civility ensures that it remains fair and respectful. By adhering to standards of civility, lawyers can argue their cases passionately while refraining from personal attacks or disrespectful behavior. This preserves the dignity of the profession and maintains the focus on the merits of the case rather than personal animosity.

Enhancing communication and collaboration

Legal disputes can be emotionally charged and complex. In such situations, legal civility is crucial in fostering effective communication and collaboration among legal professionals. Respectful dialogue and professional conduct contribute to a constructive exchange of ideas, leading to better outcomes for clients and a more efficient resolution of legal matters. Moreover, maintaining civility promotes trust and rapport among lawyers, facilitating the possibility of reaching settlements or alternative dispute resolutions outside the courtroom.

Improving access to justice

Legal civility is directly linked to improving access to justice for all individuals. When legal professionals prioritize respectful behavior, it creates an environment where clients feel heard, valued, and understood. Civility in legal proceedings ensures that all parties have an equal opportunity to present their arguments and have their voices heard. By treating opposing parties with dignity and respect, lawyers contribute to a fair and balanced judicial process, which is vital for upholding the principles of justice.

Preserving the public’s perception

The public’s perception of the legal system is shaped not only by the outcomes of cases but also by the behavior of legal professionals involved. Legal civility plays a significant role in preserving and enhancing the public’s perception of the legal profession. When lawyers exhibit professionalism and respect towards one another, it bolsters public confidence in the fairness and effectiveness of the legal system. Conversely, uncivil behavior can undermine public trust, perpetuating negative stereotypes and eroding confidence in the legal profession as a whole.

Mitigating the emotional toll

Legal disputes can be emotionally challenging for all parties involved, including lawyers. Maintaining legal civility helps mitigate the emotional toll that the practice of law can take. By treating each other with respect, legal professionals create an environment where conflicts are addressed with dignity and professionalism. This, in turn, promotes mental well-being and reduces stress levels among lawyers, allowing them to approach their work more effectively and efficiently.

The heart of our profession

Legal civility lies at the heart of the legal profession, playing a crucial role in upholding the principles of justice, fairness, and professionalism. By promoting respectful behavior, legal practitioners enhance communication, preserve the adversarial process, and improve access to justice for all individuals. Moreover, legal civility contributes to the public’s perception of the legal system and helps mitigate the emotional toll of legal practice.

Let’s all try to emulate the careers and professionalism that Gary, Carl, Gretchen, and Brian exemplify. In doing so, each of us will do a part to better the profession that we love and cherish. And maybe one day, we may be so honored as to join Gary, Carl, Gretchen, and Brian in the Hall of Fame.

Dordick, Douglas, Nelson, Panish

Copyright © 2024 by the author.
For reprint permission, contact the publisher: Advocate Magazine